When it comes to cricket, few rivalries in the world can match the intensity of India vs Pakistan. It’s not just a game; it’s an event that brings two nations to a standstill.

Netflix’s new docuseries, "The Greatest Rivalry: India vs Pakistan,"tries to capture this emotion, reliving some of the most unforgettable moments between the two teams.

But does it truly do justice to this historic battle?

Let’s dive in.

What Works?

1. First-Hand Accounts from Legends

One of the best parts of the series is that it brings in cricketing greats like Shoaib Akhtar, Virender Sehwag, Sourav Ganguly, and Inzamam-ul-Haq to tell their side of the story. Their personal experiences and behind-the-scenes stories add a lot of depth. Sehwag and Shoaib, in particular, share some fiery exchanges, just like they did on the field. These moments feel raw and real, making the documentary gripping.

2. The 1999 and 2004 Tours – A Walk Down Memory Lane

The documentary focuses on two major tours – Pakistan’s 1999 tour of India and India’s 2004 tour of Pakistan. These weren’t just cricket matches; they were politically charged moments in history. The 1999 tour happened right before the Kargil conflict, and the 2004 series was India's first visit to Pakistan in 15 years. The emotions were high, the stadiums were packed, and every ball felt like it carried the weight of history. The show does a great job of capturing this atmosphere.

3. Blending Cricket with Politics

One thing the series does well is weaving in historical footage, showing how cricket was often influenced by political tensions. It reminds us how sports and diplomacy often go hand in hand, especially for India and Pakistan. From the diplomatic handshakes to the intense face-offs on the pitch, the documentary highlights how cricket has been more than just a game for these two countries.

Where It Falls Short

1. Too Much Focus on 2004, Not Enough on Other Iconic Matches

While the 2004 tour was historic, the documentary spends too much time on it and doesn’t cover many other legendary encounters. What about the 1986 Sharjah thriller where Javed Miandad’s last-ball six broke a million Indian hearts? Or the 2007 T20 World Cup final where Misbah-ul-Haq’s scoop shot ended Pakistan’s dreams? Fans who expected a more well-rounded look at the rivalry might be a little disappointed.

2. Some Key Moments Are Missing

Cricket fans are detail-oriented, and they don’t forget things easily. That’s why the exclusion of Sachin Tendulkar’s famous 194 in Multan* has left many scratching their heads. The match is rightly known as "The Multan Test," but while Sehwag’s triple century gets a lot of coverage, Sachin’s controversial declaration by Dravid (while he was close to a double hundred) is skipped. This omission makes the documentary feel incomplete, as Tendulkar was a major figure in Indo-Pak clashes.

3. Slightly One-Sided Narrative?

Some fans have pointed out that the documentary leans slightly more towards one side in its storytelling. While both teams had their moments of glory, a more balanced approach would have made it a fairer representation of the rivalry. After all, both India and Pakistan have had their share of heartbreaks and triumphs.

Final Verdict: Worth Watching or Not?

If you’re a cricket fan who grew up watching India vs Pakistan matches with your family, this documentary will definitely bring back memories. The interviews, old footage, and intense stories make it a nostalgic watch. However, if you were expecting a deep dive into the full history of this rivalry, you might be left wanting more.

Final Rating: 3.5/5

– Great for casual viewers, but hardcore cricket fans may feel a few key moments were left out.